A recent report from Capgemini reveals a troubling disconnect between brands' perceptions of customer experiences and the reality reported by consumers. As artificial intelligence increasingly mediates interactions in digital commerce, brands risk losing customer loyalty due to overconfidence and misalignment with consumer expectations.
The report, titled “Reimagining customer experience: Human-led, AI-powered,” highlights that while organizations invest heavily in AI and automation, they remain out of touch with customer sentiments. The study surveyed 9,500 consumers across 16 countries, along with 1,200 executives and front-line staff in various sectors, including banking, retail, and healthcare, to draw its conclusions.
Despite a decade of advancements, the findings echo a similar report from 2017, which exposed a significant gap between brands’ self-assessments and actual consumer opinions. In that earlier study, 75% of organizations considered themselves customer-centric, while only 30% of consumers agreed. This disparity persists, with the latest data indicating that executives believe 84% of customers would recommend their products based on their experiences. In stark contrast, only 45% of customers expressed similar sentiments.
These discrepancies extend beyond mere recommendations. Only 14% of consumers associate positive emotions like confidence with their experiences, while a staggering 77% of executives believe their customers feel this way. This misalignment suggests that brands are not only misjudging customer sentiment but also risk underinvesting in crucial areas that could enhance customer satisfaction.
Martin Kihn, SVP Strategy at Salesforce, comments on the implications of these findings, stating, "AI agents are quickly becoming the engine behind modern CX, powering personalisation, proactive outreach, and fast, accurate resolution across channels." He emphasizes AI's potential to improve speed and consistency in customer interactions while allowing human agents to focus on more complex issues that require empathy and nuance.
As AI technology rapidly evolves, the report indicates that 52% of consumers are now using generative AI tools—such as ChatGPT and others—over traditional search methods for product research. Additionally, 58% believe that AI agents can save time by automating recurring transactions. These trends signify a shift in consumer behavior and expectations, with AI becoming integral to the shopping experience.
This transformation necessitates a critical reassessment by brands of how they engage with customers across various platforms. Consumers frequently navigate apps, websites, stores, and social media, yet often encounter disjointed experiences. The Capgemini report warns that this lack of a seamless customer journey, combined with executives' overestimation of customer satisfaction, could lead to significant fallout in brand loyalty.
As major technology firms and retailers continue to deploy AI agents capable of handling various consumer tasks—from product searches to transaction negotiations—the urgency for brands to realign with customer expectations intensifies. The findings serve as a wake-up call for leaders to bridge the perception gap and invest in genuine customer engagement strategies that resonate with the evolving digital commerce landscape.
The stories that move AI & crypto markets — before the market reacts.
Free. 7am ET. Five stories. 62,400 readers.
